Lab notes · 18 November 2026

One run on a 78,000-word rough draft.

Our first lab note was a polished manuscript with no bible. This one is the opposite: The Dusk Crossing, a cozy fantasy novel, in a complete rough draft of 28 chapters and 78,335 words, with more canon than most books carry. Its author let us use it for this test.

The canon came in five documents, 8,985 words in all: a book bible, a chapter outline, a series map, an editor's pass and a continuity ledger. We set the book to Early draft, the hardest edit Ninth Draft makes, ran all four passes on every chapter once, then asked for a Story read. Nothing was run twice.

The run

Every chapter, four passes, took 44 minutes on our own setup, and the Story read two more. Of 697 suggestions, 262 reached the author. The gate held back 435.

PassProposedReached the authorHeld by the gate
Continuity31274
Voice467225242
Line edit19710187
Proof202
All four697262435

Continuity's 27 include 15 questions: where the answer was the author's to give, it asked rather than changed anything, and questions go straight to the author. The free checks, which use no AI and no words, found 556 more things to look at in Review and highlighted 52 common tells.

A slip against the bible

The bible locks the deckhand, Len, as they/them, and the chapters keep to it, except once, in chapter 11:

Continuitylocked factCh 11
The grandmother took his their hand without the fight this time.

The hand on the low stairs is Len's: they call "Climbing" in the line before, and the grandmother refused Len's hand on the way down. The canon locks Len as they/them, and this chapter uses "they" for Len everywhere else.

Book Bible, Locked people: Len Calder, 16, they/them; Continuity ledger: Len … they/them

Gate passed. The hand is Len's, and canon locks Len as they/them, so this fixes a real pronoun error.

The story clock slipped too. The continuity ledger gives each chapter its day, and in chapter 20 three lines measured time in weeks. Continuity fixed each one from the ledger, and the gate passed all three:

Chapter 20, against the continuity ledger
  1. I sat a woman in the jump last three week nights back

    Gate passed. The jump-seat was Day 6 dusk and this is Day 9, so 'three nights back' fixes a real clock slip.

  2. He had waited three six weeks days for a day-hand.

    Gate passed. Kael was sent to 'ask day' on Day 3 night, so six days is correct; three weeks is the age of the hold.

  3. He had also, for two six weeks days, let a spelling sit in a cover like a pin in a hole

    Gate passed. The cover note was written Day 3 night, so six days is right; two weeks confused the note with the hold.

Not every question was about the draft. In chapter 18, Continuity found the prose and the ledger disagreeing, and thought the ledger was the likelier mistake:

Continuitycanon driftCh 18
The nib sat, a black wet, not a name.

Draft Continuity's time table says Ch 18 is 'nib on page, no ink', but the chapter puts ink on the page: a black wet in the dent, ink in Kael's thumbprint, a black comma on the bunk-edge, and a black print on the ladder rung. The prose seems deliberate, so the continuity file probably needs updating, unless 'no ink' was meant to rule out a mark on the packet.

Draft Continuity: Time table, Ch 18 = 'nib on page, no ink'

An edit the gate passed

The editor's pass gives one character a verbal habit and caps it: Osa may say “Don't you”, twice a chapter at most, and nobody else may borrow it. In chapter 20, Tallen borrows it.

VoicecapCh 20
Don’t you mix my box with Harn’s paper.Keep my box out of Harn’s paper.

Tallen borrows Osa's tic; this chapter is already over the cap.

'Don't you' is Osa's mouth only, twice per chapter max.

Gate passed. Tallen may not use Osa's tic, and the replacement keeps his meaning and clip.

That's typical of what got through. 123 of the 225 voice edits that reached the author cite the book's own canon, in their rule or in the gate's reason. The editor's pass had listed the habits the draft should lose, such as the bible's rules showing through as narration, and the run found them on the page. In chapter 3, Voice cut “Magic was a passenger. It did not get the sounding.” and the gate agreed: “'Magic was a passenger' is the bible's rule leaking onto the page; the scene shows it without the maxim.”

An edit the gate held back

Here Voice wanted to cut the second sentence, from chapter 8, citing the bible's rule that the engine, Nine, has no opinions. The gate read the line again:

VoicetellCh 8
A cough answered her. The Wender-9 deciding, again, to be a machine.

Gives Nine an attitude and a cute button. Osa treats Nine as a mule, but the narrator shouldn't also make it wry. The cough closes the exchange.

tell: objects with attitudes; Bible: Nine has no opinions

Gate held this back. Misreads the line, which denies Nine an attitude and fits the bible's 'it does not have opinions'.

The gate held back 242 voice edits and 187 line edits. Where an edit touched a scene the editor's pass asks to protect, it said so, 22 times. Line edit had the hardest time: an early draft invites rewrites, and only 10 of 197 passed. 42 were held as unusual edits, changing a passage's length more than a line edit should.

What the gate didn't check

Held back also counts 55 edits the gate never gave a verdict on, 54 of them in chapters 21 and 26. Those chapters arrived with so many edits that the gate's reply ran to its length limit, and it holds back what it hasn't checked. One was the slip it had passed a chapter earlier:

Continuitystory clockCh 21
“Last Three week nights ago,” Kael said, “a woman needed the wood and I didn’t put her in your hold.

Sade Vell sat the jump-seat on Day 6 dusk; this scene is Day 9 afternoon, so the event was three nights ago, not last week.

Draft Continuity: Time table, Ch 12 = Day 6 dusk (jump-seat); Ch 21 = Day 9 afternoon

Gate held this back. The gate returned no verdict for this edit.

They stay readable under Held back, and the author can still accept them. It's a limit a busy early draft could reach, and this run reached it.

Since this run, the gate's length limit grows with the number of edits it reads, a reply that still runs long is sent again in halves, and any edit it can't judge is marked as not checked, never as held back by the gate, with Check these again to send it once more. In a later run on six of these chapters, with the same canon, every edit got a verdict, and the chapter 21 slip above passed the gate and reached the author.

The Story read

The Story read takes the canon and a short summary of every chapter and reads the book for its whole shape, the way an editor reads a first draft. Its verdict:

The spine holds: the clock, the contract, the seat, Len and the maps braid cleanly. No later book's plot is stolen, and the kind answer lands without a twist. The weak point is the contract's endgame. Kael circles the packet in several chapters, lets Dessa's Day 9 deadline lapse, then returns the paper the next morning, so the one 'no' risks reading as staying by default, which is the flaw the book exists to break. Secondary drag comes from stock passengers who repeat across dusks, a mystery Kael could have asked about on Day 3, and Cress's two biggest choices happening off the page.

It made 11 findings, one high, seven medium and three low, and named 11 things to protect. The high one is “Dessa's deadline lapses before the refusal, so the 'no' reads as default”. It ties a deadline in the plot to the flaw the bible gives Kael: “That is staying as weather, the exact flaw the contract is meant to force him past.”

At least two findings were wrong, and both came from reading summaries rather than chapters. One said chapter 18 adds a contract term; its summary had dropped a “not”, and the chapter says: “The dusk-window not forbidden. The hours forbidding it anyway.” The other asked chapter 28 to drop a line its prose already explains.

Caveats

One book, one run, and every verdict comes from an AI model; the author decides. The free checks counted the setting's own place names as repeated phrases. Review says “the inner mouth” comes up 36 times in the book, and the inner mouth is a place on the river. Treat this as a field report, not a benchmark.

More lab notes